Sunday, March 13, 2011

Wrapping It Up!

Launch after launch, adjustment after adjustment, blog post after blog post the end has finally come. Our rocket has been through more than we thought was possible. Much was learned during this project; aerodynamics, center of mass and pressure, making efficient use of what little materials we had, improving from past mistakes, and that duct tape is your best friend. We learned that by paying close attention to the finer details, we'd be able to drastically improve the success of our launches and flight times. Making adjustments and troubleshooting our errors was a necessary component in ensuring our success. After thoroughly analyzing all aspects of the process, we've gathered a sufficient amount of data to collaborate with.


List of Materials Used:
  • Two 2-liter soda bottles
    • Two additional 2-liter bottles were also used later on
  • Four 3cm cardboard fins
  • Duct tape
  • Hot glue gun
  • String
  • Box Cutters and scissors
  • Plastic trash bag
  • Water
  • A ball pump
  • A clamp-contraption to hold the bottle in place
Design:
Days 1 & 2) The design of our rocket morphed over the course of the project. In the beginning, we started out with no modifications whatsoever. We then added two 3cm cardboard fins, wrapped in duct tape to prevent water damage, parallel to each other on the sides of the bottle. This was done to add stability to the rocket. The design is depicted in the image below:
Day 3) After analyzing the flight time of the rocket and how the fins failed, further modifications were made. A cone was needed to make the bottle more aerodynamic. So we cut the top half of another 2-liter soda bottle, placed it atop the opposite end of the opening and fashioned it into a cone. The plastic trash bag was cut and shaped into what we thought was a nicely formed circle and four strings connected to the bottle via duct tape were attached to it. We also added two more fins of equal size and shape to the bottle, however, we made a critical error in the application process--the fins were upside down. Despite our irritation for making such a careless mistake, we proceeded to launch the rocket in an attempt to gather more knowledge on what works best. However, our scientific endeavors were not enough to keep the fins attached to the bottle. In the image below, you can clearly see one of the four fall off upon the launching of the craft. Two more fell off in mid-air.
Another error we ran into was the deployment of our parachute--as seen in the image below:
Day 4) We cleaned off the old glue residue from the fins and reattached them correctly this time around. Since we were having difficulty keeping the fins on the bottle, we took a look at Joel/Kyrie's and Jayden/Jessica's rockets and replicated their fin-attachments. By applying duct tape alongside the fins, it doubled the adhesive of the hot glue and made for a great reinforcement. We had hoped the parachute would deploy if we'd folded it differently, but the folding wasn't the issue and we didn't realize this till afterwards.


Day 5) On the final day of launching, we knew what to keep and what needed to be modified. First we tackled our cone. By cutting another tube off of another bottle, we duct taped it to the cone to make it large enough to hold the parachute. We then hole-punched a hole into the cone and tied a string to it, which we then attached to the bottle. This was done so the cone would go wherever the bottle would. Our next issue was our parachute; the strings were too long, the shape wasn't working, and overall it was our biggest problem in our design. We first untangled the strings and cut them at equal lengths. Then we folded and taped off different areas of the parachute to make it more circular. In order to test the effectiveness of the parachute before the launch, I grabbed the bottle and dragged it through the air--imagine Andy flying Buzz Light Year around yelling "TO INFINITY AND BEYOND!" only I didn't scream those words...or anything for that matter. The next thing we did was add weight to the cone. We rolled a piece of duct tape into a ball, used more duct tape to keep it in the spout of the cone, and then wrapped the tip in more duct tape. The added weight was necessary to ensure our rocket would launch high enough in the air. The modifications can be seen in the images below:





Data Collection:
Launch History for Water Bottle Rockets (thanks to Jayden and Jessica for this idea)

Day 1Day 2Day 3Day 4Day 5
Launch 12.9 s3.7 s3.7 s2.9 s4.5 s
Launch 2N/A5 sN/A6.8 s4.8 s
Launch 3N/AN/AN/AN/A8.2 s
Launch 4N/AN/AN/AN/A3.8 s
Launch 5N/AN/AN/AN/A          N/A
[Bold = Modified]


For each of the launches prior to days 4 and 5, we used a psi of 50. When we realized that more water and more pressure would allow the rocket to go higher, we amped up the pressure to 70psi. Doing so gave us better results and phenomenal success in terms of air time.


Post-Lab Conclusions:
Looking back on the successes and failures of this lab, I can most definitely conclude that this lab was not only fun but very inspiring. It was through our want to succeed and desire to come out on top that we did so well. Mr. Blake didn't have to give much direction for us do well. The lab was basically a self-taught experiment and this project was incredible. To take something as simple as launching rockets in the air and to learn physics through it is mind blowing. However, before I officially wrap up the project, let us review what worked and what can be done in the future to get better results.


The four fins really made a difference in stabilizing the rocket, as did the adjustments to the parachute. If we had left the parachute as was, it wouldn't have deployed and we wouldn't have gotten the results we got. Using lots and lots of duct tape was another upside in this project. Keep in mind that you can never use too much of it. The duct tape was our life savior; from keeping things waterproof, making sure things stuck together, and adding more weight to the rocket. Another thing that worked was the placement of the strings. We noticed that the strings would tend to tangle in mid-air if they were tucked inside the cone. In order to fix that problem, we coiled a bit of the strings underneath the parachute while leaving some of it to hang on the outside. Doing so allowed the parachute to deploy faster. Also, the cone is another thing to keep in mind. Placing the cone lightly atop the bottle to cover the parachute rather than smashing it down is what should be done. You don't want the cone to be too snug on the bottle or else it won't fall off and allow the parachute to do its job. More water and more pressure really work, too.


Although, many of the rocket's features worked, there's always room for improvement. Larger fins could increase the rocket's stability. A larger parachute could catch wind faster and allow for more time in the air. 


All-in-all, this project has taught the both of us a lot. Being able to learn physics in a hands-on manner is very effective and we hope to do more labs like this. Using the blogs to further our knowledge and better assist each other was also very effective. This was a fun lab and we hope for similar labs in the near future!

Wednesday, March 9, 2011

Final Launch

Today we had our most successful launch yet. Though our time was not up to par with what was expected of us, 8.2 out of 10 seconds, it was sufficient. We were capable of increasing our time significantly by decreasing the length of our strings that connected our parachute to our rocket, and taping together equidistant edges of our parachute to decrease its surface area and increase the potential wind resistance. Since our cone was not connected to our rocket we attached a string to it and also made sure that our strings did not wrap around our fins during launch, which prevented our parachute from deploying during our first launch of the day (4.5 seconds). We were not able to continue launching because the bottle tipped while we were launching and landed on the roof. If this hadn't had happened we would have continued to launch until we made our time. Instead of standing around waiting for our rocket to fall, which would have turned out to be unsuccessful, we decided to make another rocket in five minutes to see if we could adjust our pressure (to 70 psi) and water amount significantly enough to gain a successful time but our quickly built rocket had fallen apart almost as soon as it left contact with earth. We have come a long way since our first rocket launch and learned that in order to improve you must first fail and learn from and correct your mistakes.

Monday, March 7, 2011

Don't Give Up!

Today's launch was a colossal success. Although, it took two attempts to meet the launch requirements our rocket flew higher and longer in the air than anyone else's. The accurate amount of time the rocket was in the air is unknown--the reason being that it flew so high in the air that the rocket grabbed wind and took off beyond our plane of sight. However, Mr. Blake recorded an approximated time of 6.8 seconds.
            Some adjustments were done to the design and modifications. In past launches, we had trouble with our fins staying attached to the bottle. We solved the problem by first gluing the fins onto the bottle and then reinforcing them with duct tape. The cone for the rocket was too small so we found a new bottle to create a new cone from. Our next issue was our cone where not enough weight was added to it. Rolling the tape into a ball and taping it into the funnel of the cone was an easy solution.
            In the first launch attempt, the rocket’s parachute didn’t deploy and the rocket didn’t stay in the air as long as it should’ve, giving us a time of 2.9 seconds. In the second attempt, the rocket shot higher than expected and the parachute didn’t deploy again. However, it fulfilled the five-second-time requirement and was surely a fun and entertaining launch to see—we regret not recording it on camera because the rocket landed in a tree alongside the road and I had to climb up to retrieve it. 
            To attain better results, we need to make some adjustments to our parachute and continue to find new ways to make it deploy. All-in-all today was a huge success and we hope for more come the next launch.

Thursday, March 3, 2011

Rocket Launch 3










This rocket launch was our best launch so far. After making a couple adjustments to our rocket, such as adding two more fins, a parachute,and a cone our rocket was able to remain airborne for more than three seconds. Prior to launch 2 we glued two fins to opposite sides of our rocket which had fallen off. We made an adjustment to this by adding two more fins equidistant apart and this time put the fins on in a more unconventional way, which may appear to be upside down. In an attempt to prevent the fins from falling off during take off again, we used more glue and allowed more time for it to set. Unfortunately, this attempt was unsuccessful,which is why for our next launch we will attempt to duct tape the fins to the rocket instead. During our launch, our parachute did not deploy which may have been due to the string that we had loosely wrapped around it. Therefore during our next attempt, we will either think of a better way to prevent it from deploying too early or not wrap it. The cone that we had used was made from the top of our other bottle and unfortunately did not appear to have helped our rocket, so we will have to think of a way to fix this. Overall, this was a successful launch because we improved our time and learned what to and not to do.

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Rocket Launch 2

In order to increase the amount of time that our rocket was airborne, David and I added two fins to the opposite sides of the bottle. We created the fins by cutting pieces of cardboard into congruent triangles and to increase water resistance, we duct taped them tightly. The fins were meant to balance the rocket's center of gravity and therefore were placed as low as possible. Though this addition to our rocket did not increase our time as much as we hoped it would, it was an educational experience. We realized that we must connect our fins to our rocket better by possibly using a stronger or more adhesive and possibly add two more fins. We managed to successfully launch our rockets without injuring any people or objects and projected it relatively well.

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Launch #2

Two launches with two different rockets took place. The first launch was a repeat of the previous day's where the water bottle had no modifications. The launch was yet another success--then came the second rocket's turn. 
Modifying the bottle took up most of our time today. As Tiare and I searched the Internet for rocket designs, we also debated on certain modification ideas. After a few minutes of brainstorming, we chose to add a couple of fins at the base of the rocket for stability and we'd analyze their effectiveness in the launch, hoping they'd create the needed drag in the air for stability.
3cm cardboard fins were cut in the shape of a triangle. In order to prevent water damage, the fins were thoroughly wrapped in duct tape and then hot glued on parallel sides of the bottle. After a stressful launching setup, our fins were an utter fail as they flew off in mid-flight. 

Despite the fins failing, the launch was successful (as seen in the image below) and the rocket was in the air for a decent amount of time. For future launches, we'll find a new and innovative way to attach the fins and any added features to stabilize the rocket. 


There's A First For Everything

Launching our rocket wasn't nearly as difficult as some made it out to be. By following Mr. Blake's example and watching other successful launches, Tiare and I were able to launch our rocket with equal success. We first made sure our setup was ready and everything was in place before starting the launching procedure. After a decent amount of air-pumping, we pulled the string and gazed up at the rocket suspended high up above our heads. With it landing safely on the ground, we can conclude that our launch was very successful, indeed.

Tiare and I hope our success remains in place for future rocket launches. 

Monday, February 28, 2011

Rocket Launch 1

Our first rocket launch was relatively successful. We initially had a slight problem connecting the pump properly but eventually realized that it was due to a faulty pump. Our rocket flew straight up and landed back on the ground without going too far of course. Therefore I consider our first launch a success. The rocket launching set up was not as difficult as we had expected it to be and we made sure that we completed each step of the set up carefully and meticulously. The rocket appeared to have remained in the air for a decent amount of time had the set up had a very limited number of problems.

Additional Resources

This website contains the equations that show the physics behind water bottle rockets. The equations allow you to see how the water bottle rocket works. It allows you to see not just what the rocket is doing, but the contributions of the external forces acting upon the rocket as well.
It mentions the assumptions that are to be made when calculating the equations and breaks down the different parts of the equations so that you understand what is going on within the rocket during different periods of the launch.

Link can be found here.

Sunday, February 27, 2011

Water Bottle Rockets

The site offers complete and helpful instruction on how to create your rockets from listing the materials needed and the correct steps to follow in order to construct a working bottle rocket. With simple step-by-step instructions, including visuals to aid to your work, this 5-step site is more than helpful. The sites also includes a PDF file and discussion area for water bottle rockets. For all those who aren't as rocket-savy as others, I encourage you to check out this website for any help you feel necessary.

Link can be found here.